New York Post: Brewer Clients File Lawsuit Over Southampton Tragedy
December 15, 2025 – The New York Post reports that a prominent New York City and Southampton family — Craig and Jacqueline Huff, and their son, Garrett — face lawsuits over a catastrophic golf cart crash.
Brewer clients John Mascali and Heather Dailey recently filed lawsuits in Suffolk County Supreme Court – alleging they suffered serious, long-term injuries in a golf cart rollover near the Huff family’s Southampton residence. According to the complaint, Garrett Huff drove his parents’ golf cart at high speed toward a roundabout on the night of August 3, 2024, veering left without warning and attempting a dangerous stunt that caused the cart to flip. As passengers, Mascali and Dailey were reportedly ejected from the vehicle and knocked unconscious.
As reported by the Post on December 14, the vehicle overturned, “violently hurling” Mascali and Dailey to the pavement and knocking them unconscious, according to their Suffolk County Supreme Court lawsuits against Huff and his parents, Craig and Tracey Huff, seeking unspecified damages.
The plaintiffs allegedly sustained multiple traumatic injuries, including a concussion, spinal fractures, neurological impairment, chronic pain, and other long-term medical complications. According to the Post, the suit further alleges that Garrett had a history of prior golf cart accidents, including one that “previously injured a friend’s hand,” and that his parents were aware of this pattern yet continued to allow him unrestricted access to the vehicle.
According to the lawsuits, following the accident, Craig and Jacqueline Huff disposed of the golf cart, eliminating critical physical evidence. The lawsuit asserts claims of negligence, gross negligence, and negligent entrustment.
“This was not an accident – it was the predictable result of recklessness and a long-ignored pattern of dangerous behavior,” said William A. Brewer III, partner at Brewer, Attorneys & Counselors and counsel for plaintiffs.
Read more here: Boozy hedge-fund scion flips golf cart at $15M Hamptons estate, leaving pals with broken back and bleeding skull: suit | New York Post