Insurance Arbitration Disputes
Insurance arbitration can involve substantial coverage obligations and contested questions about the forum in which they will be decided. Brewer, Attorneys & Counselors represents clients in complex insurance disputes, including matters resolved through arbitration. The Firm addresses the agreement to arbitrate alongside the underlying policy dispute, developing a strategy that accounts for the parties, the issues submitted, and the client’s commercial objectives.
An arbitrator or panel considers the evidence and arguments presented, but whether a particular dispute belongs in arbitration requires its own analysis. Our lawyers examine the agreement containing the provision, its scope, and its application to the claims and participants. The Federal Arbitration Act provides an enforceability framework for qualifying written agreements involving commerce, subject to applicable exceptions and grounds for challenge. Its treatment of a particular insurance agreement requires consideration of the governing law and the agreement’s features; the presence of a clause alone does not settle every forum question.
The coverage or valuation dispute must also be defined on its own terms. Policy language, loss records, and the parties’ competing positions may involve different questions from those governing the arbitration process. Brewer connects those materials to the obligations and amounts at issue and develops the presentation of the client’s case. The Firm evaluates procedural and substantive issues together while keeping their legal bases distinct. Selecting arbitration does not itself establish coverage, determine the amount owed, or alter the obligations contained in the policy.
Featured Insurance Arbitration Matter
In ACE Ins. Co., Ltd. v. IMC Fertilizer Group Inc., Brewer represented IMC Fertilizer Group in an insurance dispute arising from an incident at a chemical plant. The matter proceeded to arbitration in London and concerned coverage for the resulting claims.
Insurance arbitration is one dimension of the Firm’s broader Insurance Litigation practice.